Five years after her senior intercounty debut, two All-Ireland titles and an All-Star award later, Meath’s vice-captain Mary-Kate Lynch, could be forgiven for resting on her laurels. Having been part of the most successful period in the Royals’ Ladies Football history, the 23-year-old Sports Psychology student carries the weight of her achievements with a refreshing combination of modesty and self-assurance.
This Meath woman could just as easily have picked up her two celtic crosses in another sporting pursuit. A talented Sean-Nós dancer off the pitch, she qualified to compete at provincial level of the Fleadh Cheoil, but couldn’t perform on the day due to a football clash. While the two sports complement each with “co-ordination… timing and feet movement” common to both, when offered a hypothetical dilemma by her father, of choosing a football or a dancing final on given day, “football” was the definitive answer for Mary-Kate.
“[I] still don’t think I’m very good a football” says the Summerhill native, when asked if there’s a particular moment where she realised her abilities might take her to greater heights in the game, before revealing that she made her Senior club debut aged 14. While progress on the underage intercounty scene was slower, a move to full-back after joining the Meath minors and marking Vikki Wall in an in-house challenge game against the Seniors are significant turning points in her journey.
Vikki WallMary-Kate LynchTurning Point, marking Senior Star Vikki Wall in in-house game
Until then, she was thinking “this is my last year with Meath football, I’ll never get on that Senior team”. Although she only found out this detail years later, her strong performance against the AFLW and Rugby 7’s star Wall, was enough to impress senior management and the call-up gave Mary-Kate the belief that she “mightn’t be too bad at this [senior football] craic”.
Fast forward to today. Herself, Vikki and the rest of the Meath panel will jet south-west to take on reigning All-Ireland champions Kerry, at Austin Stack Park . Reuniting with their 2022 All-Ireland final opponents, the Royals sit one position behind Kerry in the league in third position, on the back of two disappointing defeats to Dublin and Kildare.
The flight will save the squad four-and-a-half hours of travel each way, which makes the world of difference to students on the panel like Mary-Kate, balancing their studies with sporting commitments. “We did it two years ago… it’s actually great”. As one of the panel’s only players living away from home, she’ll now have the chance to travel home from UL on Thursday evening and “get a full day at home”, either side of the trip to Tralee.
Living away for the first time, having commuted from Summerhill during her three years in Maynooth University, Mary-Kate is enjoying her new-found independence Shannonside, even if she does miss the “comfort of [her] mother’s cooking and cleaning”.
Despite it only being her first year in UL, she was named captain of the college’s O’Connor Cup Squad for this season, something she was “very surprised” about. Having already captained Maynooth in her final year, and becoming vice-captain of her county, her leadership qualities are clearly not a surprise to the squads that she is a part of.
Mary-Kate in O’Connor Cup action as captain of UL at Maguire’s Field
Self-described as “bit quieter” in her younger days, her role at full-back means “you have to be a communicator, you have to be a leader… because you have the best view of the pitch”. It’s a role that she feels like she’s “grown into” and one that’s becoming a bit more comfortable to her now as the years go on.
The Royals will need both those leadership skills and fast feet to be in flying form this afternoon and beyond if they’re to pick up some silverware in 2025. From listening to Mary-Kate Lynch this week, you’d be hard-pressed to back against it.
On our very first day as Physical Education students we were introduced to the NASPE’s purpose of Physical Education – “To gain the skills, knowledge and dispositions to be physically active for a lifetime” (1). Over the course of the following four years, we’ve been exposed to a variety of different experiences that, for better or worse, have shaped how we’re going to go about developing the aforementioned competencies for continuous Physical Activity (PA) in our students.
‘We’ve come a long way since that day’ Day 1 at UL for the Class of ’24, November 2020
The notion that I, as a 20-something just out of college (albeit further along that age-scale than my colleagues…), have all the answers to instilling these abilities is absurd. However, if I didn’t have the self-belief or desire to attain as many of those answers as possible, why would I bother getting into this gig in the first place?
When describing a physically educated person, James MacAllister(2) speaks of “those that have learned to arrange their lives in such a way that the habitual activities they freely engage in make a distinctive contribution to their wider flourishing”. While those that know me might not quite describe me as ‘flourishing’ day-to-day, I can certainly attest to the continuing positive impact that participating in regular PA has on my life.
I am very fortunate that sport and PA have been a constant part of my life thanks to the support of family, coaches, peers and teachers throughout my formative years. Regardless of my relative ability in these sports, simply being able to effectively participate and/or having the requisite knowledge to hold a conversation with others on the subject has been a passport to so many positive life experiences for me. Whether that be starting a new job, joining new teams or travelling to different parts of the country and beyond, my interest in sport has smoothened the pathway to finding my feet and making friends quickly.
‘A Passport to Life’ Some of my many habitual Physical Activities throughout the years
With so many children and adolescents dropping out of extracurricular sport and PA due to academic demands and other external factors, the time spent promoting and extoling the virtues of PA in the PE classroom is therefore, more important than ever. Ultimately, that is why my values and beliefs as a PE teacher are inspired by the idea that the relationship between PA involvement and wider flourishing in everyday life is symbiotic.
#StopTheDrop
So how do you go about achieving this rather grandiose idea? For me, Scott Kretchmar’s(3) inquiry of PE teachers as to whether they teach for “joy and delight” is especially relevant here. As a former accountant and worker in many an office throughout the years, the very notion that my ‘office’ is now the PE hall, the sports field or the classroom (oftentimes all three in one day) is something that elicits great joy and delight for me. I feel that bringing this energy and personality into my PE classes is crucial to fostering those same positive feelings towards PA among my students.
A Good Day at the ‘Office’ Fresher B Mens Football Management
Every student is unique and will have different levels of ability and motivation for participating in your PE class. In order for everyone to effectively participate and thus, begin to flourish in the lesson, students must develop their competence and confidence through activities with a high chance of success. Building on the work of @ImSporticus(4), these activities must be designed in a way that makes them more enjoyable than the alternative, non-participation. With this in mind, when it comes to teacher involvement in my own lessons, the ‘Do as I say, not as I do’ approach is not an option.
When teaching units such as dance or gymnastics, PA’s that will likely be new and nerve-wracking for some students, it is imperative that you show your vulnerable side and that you are willing to throw yourself into the activity with 100% effort, otherwise they can go disastrously wrong.
‘Do as I say, Do as I do’ i-PLAY Dance Class, PESS, November 2022
During these classes I also try to ensure that structure doesn’t come at the expense of activity and experimentation. There can be a tendency, especially with younger class groups to micro-manage students’ behaviour to ensure everybody remains on task. However, once strict rules about respectful interaction between peers are in place, with an end goal clearly communicated, I endeavour to let students explore the multitude of different ways to get there within the parameters of the activity e.g., dance, orienteering etc. without too much teacher intervention.
Personally, it’s the self-discovery of your newfound abilities and skills that is where the ‘craic’ comes from a lot of the time. Harnessing my own experiences as a student/participant to create an environment for my students to achieve similarly is the challenge, while also ‘letting them play’ as it were.
Through enjoyment comes flourishment Yours truly (No. 17) in Clonkeen College Staff 100m 2023
Of course there have been, and there will be many days where I haven’t exactly been filled with joy coming into work and keeping up the requisite energy and enthusiasm levels can be difficult. Regardless of what activities you have planned for your lessons, you can be sure many of your students will also have similar feelings during some of your lessons. It’s unavoidable.
For me, novelty and variety has contributed so much to my enjoyment of PE in schools and PA in general. That is why exposing students to as many different types of PA in the PE class is paramount if they are to find the activity that compliments their abilities, interests and lifestyles most effectively. Essentially, allowing them to flourish.
While the path of least resistance for many PE teachers is go with who in their class shouts loudest and lead an invasion game (e.g., soccer, basketball) heavy schedule of activities, there are better uses of democratic pedagogies(5) to give all students a say in the way their lessons are laid out. A method that has worked in my experience is selecting sports/activities from certain strands of the curriculum e.g., badminton & volleyball from the net games category and giving students a say in how they’re delivered. What sport would you like to try? What curriculum model shall we learn these sports through? Could we combine the two sports?
‘Variety is the spice of Life’ UL Academy for Children, Thomond Primary School, Feb ’24
By exposing your students to different curriculum models such as Sport Education and TGfU (Teaching Games for Understanding), they will have an idea what each process involves. It keeps activities fresh and engaging, gives students an input into what they are learning, all the while ensuring that you are giving them as many opportunities to find PA they can enjoy and habitually participate in throughout their lives.
In reflecting on my journey as a Physical Education student and almost a real-life teacher, it’s evident that the essence of our profession lies not in having all the answers, but in the pursuit of self-improvement and the commitment to instil a love, or at the very least, a fondness for physical activity. The joy and delight I derive from habitual PA participation directly correlates with the prospering aspects of my life. Through teaching for this joy and delight, embracing my vulnerability and incorporating novelty in my teaching methods, I hope to not only keep my classes engaging but also empower students to discover their passions. Ultimately, this paves the way for their flourishing in both the classroom and beyond.
References:
(1) Ennis, C. D. (2010). On their own: Preparing students for a lifetime. Journal of Physical Education, Recreation & Dance, 81(5), 17-22.
(2) MacAllister, J. (2013). The ‘physically educated’person: Physical education in the philosophy of Reid, Peters and Aristotle. Educational Philosophy and Theory, 45(9), 908-920.
(5) Gerdin, G., Philpot, R., Smith, W., Schenker, K., Mordal Moen, K., Larsson, L., … & Westlie, K. (2021). Teaching for student and societal wellbeing in HPE: nine pedagogies for social justice. Frontiers in Sports and Active Living, 3, 702922.
On this very day 64 years ago, two matriarchs went into labour with their respective third children. One of these women was Queen Elizabeth II. The other, much less famed but no less formidable, was my own Grandmother, Mary Lynch. The identity of that particular Royal Baby, I’ll let the reader do their own research on, but it’s certainly arguable that the child of Mary Lynch’s went on to have a more positive impact on the world. There’s no question she did in our lives anyway.
Quenn Elizabeth IIMary Lynch
In case her identity wasn’t apparent by now, Mary Lynch’s child is of course my own darling Mother, Máire Lynch who turns the grand old age of 64 today, not that you’d know to look at her… On the publishing of the first blog in this series, which focused on the unique way that Fathers and Sons express their love towards each other, it’s safe to say she’s been more than a bit perturbed by the absence of a similar post in her own honour.
Oftentimes we wait until somebody has passed or it’s too late to express how we feel about them. Therefore, I think it is really important that we share some of these feelings with them while they’re still knocking around. It should be clarified that this ain’t no eulogy, however, see this post as the killing of the two aforementioned birds with the one blog post as it were…
‘Butter wouldn’t melt’ – A rare photo of Ma on family holiday in France circa 2004
When tasked with writing a similar essay on my Mother 15 years ago in a first year English class, I described her at one point as “cynical, especially when it comes to politics and religion”. While I haven’t been able to find the offending copybook to corroborate this, unsurprisingly, Ma has never forgotten about it. All these years later, this description is probably still accurate, but there is so much more to the woman than that.
For starters, she is an Ag Science graduate born and reared on the Longmile Road in Walkinstown. She is unlikely to be boxed off into any of your traditional categories. As the ‘Tom Boy’ in a family of three, she excelled in the underage camogie ranks. Many of her peers and those who saw her play would identify her most effective attribute to be her low centre of gravity and the use of her backside to disrupt opponents. A “mullacker”, a “spoiler”, “she’d stop a good player”, all the cliched backhanded compliments. On reflection, they’re not too dissimilar to the playing style of her sons.
After a few good years of third level camogie at UCD, there came an early retirement at the age of 23. Academic commitments, social commitments, bouts of jersey pulling… the pitfalls of many a promising hurler, both before her time and since, all played a role in the decision. Her near record attendance at Fitzgibbon Cup victory banquets I’m sure goes some way to softening the blow of the potential prolonged playing career.
Máire Lynch x The Fitz, 43 Years on
That love of sport has been transferred onto both my brother Mike and I, and has been a passport to so many different enriching life experiences for all three of us. Her commitment to this passion (and perhaps madness) was most in evidence in the years following her separation from my father. During this time, she moved to Dundalk, a mere 90-minute spin from the leafy suburbs of Dublin 18…
Weekly, she would collect Mike and myself from school on a Friday evening and bring us up the M1 that night to stay with her for the weekend. Regularly however, I would have a match on the Saturday which she would drive me back down for, return to Dundalk that evening, before repeating the whole process again for Mike’s match the following morning. No questions asked, no fear of her kids playing sport away from their school friends. Always our Number One supporter. Looking back on the insanity of it all, we had some incredible craic on the road in the car and I’m so grateful to her for the effort, but it really was mad.
‘The Jewell in the Crown of the North East’, Dundalk
In more recent years, as I’ve gotten a bit older, we’ve travelled the length and breadth of the country going to games in all codes, predominantly the four Gaelic Games. As a result we have some incredible shared experiences to show for them. No matter the occasion, or how tight the journey time might be, if I suggest that there’s an event we might like to go to, once she’s physically able, she is always outwardly enthusiastic about the prospect, even if I have her driven demented on the inside.
Her enthusiasm and support of her sons doesn’t cease with our sporting endeavours or interests. On my suggestion that I pack in an accounting job that I wasn’t enjoying in favour of returning to college for four more years, to become a teacher (at significant financial expense) she was the first to get on board with the spirit of the idea. It should be added, this came after a healthy dose of realism and “are you for real?” style questions, we are talking about Mary Lynch’s daughter after all.
“Don’t tell me you want to do another degree…”
Once the prospect became real, she drove us to the necessary open days, canvassed the relevant familial support and celebrated most fervently when the offer was accepted. Throughout the degree, and on my various teaching placements, she has been a tremendous sounding board for advice as well as simply listening to Mike and I ramble (and occasionally moan) about the various goings on in school life. Her own 30 plus years of teaching experience blended with a healthy scepticism of chancers, is invaluable to us both and we’re very lucky to have her putting up with us.
All of this support in more recent times has come in the face of some health challenges. A stroke suffered in the school building in 2013, combined with a lack of support from crucial stakeholders, ultimately put paid to her teaching career a few years later. A job she absolutely adored and was incredibly good at, this is something that still rancours with her to this day.
I’ve experienced her ability first hand; she taught me Economics as an extra subject for the Leaving Cert. I also have countless experiences of running into past pupils of hers in her company and individually. To hear the positive impacts that she has had on the lives of so many of her students is incredible. It’s these experiences, coupled with her lost years in the classroom that have definitely inspired me to choose the career I have chosen. I’m sure Mike would say something similar.
Not one to lie down, Ma is continuing to put down busy year after busy year. She has worked as a bus escort, in English language schools and as child minder to name a few recent occupations, just to keep the few bob coming in. She has also single handedly revamped the back garden, become a DIY aficionado, all the while still cleaning up after her grown-adult children. It’s nothing short of remarkable.
As I’ve already alluded to, it’s still the sport and attending matches that keeps her going. Her health difficulties and the passion that she has for the sports teams she holds dear, as you can imagine are not the greatest mixture. After her own children’s sporting exploits, Dublin GAA teams are probably those that get her most exercised. Big days involving the Dubs in Croke Park have had to be foregone on occasion as a result.
Therefore, the most enjoyable weekend we have spent together so far, recency bias acknowledged, is that of the All-Ireland Men’s Football Final this year. The Saturday evening was spent with Ma in the driving seat, en route to Thurles to see the Dublin Ladies team defeat Cork in their own semi-final.
Thurles 1984, Centenary All Ireland SHC Day
Thurles, the town and stadium synonymous with so many Munster Finals and Centenary All-Irelands of her youth. The Ladies’ victory, the venue, Spotify’s uncanny ability to play the right tune, all evoked stories and memories that allowed us to dream of what it might be like if the Dubs could just win the next day.
Ma and Mike (excuse the Cork jersey) on the pitch in Semple Stadium, Thurles
As is the nature of All-Ireland tickets, they are hard to come by. We ended up watching the match from two different parts of the stadium. I, up in the Cusack Stand, Ma, on the Hill. Naturally I was somewhat worried for how she’d cope with the stress of it all. Before throw-in, I managed to spot her amongst the crowd on the Hill, in the usual spot beside my uncles and other family. She’s amongst Dubs, she’ll be ok I thought…
Thankfully, the Dubs got the job done on the day. However, it was only after James McCarthy raised Sam Maguire and ‘The Boys are Back in Town’ rang out around Croke Park that the crowning moment of the day occurred for me. I glanced towards Hill 16 to see a rain-soaked wild woman, partially covered by an Elvery’s Poncho, arms flailing all over the shop to the sound of Thin Lizzy. Both the Jacks and Máire Lynch were back.
The Jacks are Back, Ok!
Celebrations spilled into Cusack’s, Mooney’s and finally onto Mulligans before a scamper to catch the last Dart home on the Sunday evening. While the rest of the county stumbled into work on the Monday, Ma tactically rested up and was rearing to go again come the “Homecoming” in Smithfield that evening. More shouting and more dancing ensued there, before heading for Brogan’s to round off this long, special weekend. What was left of her voice gave us a rendition of Raglan Road and more Vodka-Cokes were consumed than had been for the preceding two years. Who do you think caused us to miss the last bus? I’ve never been happier to get a taxi in my life. Magical.
And so, it seems fitting that this weekend of all weekends, we will once again be on the road. We’ll travel to Abbeydorney for the final of that fabled Fitzgibbon Cup. I’ll be in the driving seat; I owe her enough lifts at this point… as I’ll be doing the social media for the three-in-row chasing UL Wolves. When we started out going to all of these matches together, I think we both dreamed I might get to play in one of these top-level varsity competitions myself. Even though I’m involved in a completely different capacity this weekend, I think the fact that I’m involved at all makes her just as proud if not more.
This is far from the last time we’ll ever do this, I’m looking forward to many more trips like it into the future. More hacking around the back garden. More DIY inspired by brute ignorance. More sage advice. More days on Hill 16. Many more All-Ireland Mondays in Brogan’s. There’s plenty of life in this 64-year-old yet.
In 1967, Paul McCartney and the Beatles proffered the question “Will you still need me… when I’m 64?”. If Ma could work Spotify by herself, I’m sure she’d have played the song to the death this week, she’s certainly sang it enough… The answer to this question is ‘Yes, of course I do’. More than ever in fact, à la Flavia, with a raging will to live. I love you Ma. Happy Birthday.
You know what they say about buses, waiting ages for one and then two come along at once! The same is evidently true in blogspace as we have a second post in the space of two months after a near 20-month hiatus. This time it’s Arsenal manager, Mikel Arteta’s revelations that he has replaced the word ‘substitutes’ around London Colney with ‘Impacters’. Following in the footsteps of former England Rugby Head Coach, Eddie Jones’ who coined the term ‘Finishers’ for his own replacements, Arteta’s terminology alteration was subject to mixed reviews on social media. As somebody who’s spent plenty of time in my own sporting “career” in that very position, I found the idea particularly interesting and worthy of some further exploration.
Interesting stuff from Arteta as he reveals Arsenal now call substitutes “impacters”.
Taken a leaf out of Eddie Jones’ book, who called them “finishers”.
There is a passage in the prologue of John Leonard’s ‘Dub Sub Confidential’ which I find really encapsulates the emotional conundrum faced by those watching on from the sidelines. Leonard, understudy to legendary Dublin goalkeeper Stephen Cluxton for a number of seasons in the 00’s, describes a scene in the 2006 Leinster Final where Cluxton has misjudged a cross field pass just before half-time and ends up taking out Offaly forward Cathal Daly with “a horrendous looking professional foul”.
“The referee marches over. Time seems to slow down… every Offaly man and woman in the stadium is screaming – ‘OFF OFF OFF OFF’… I hold my breath and hear my heart lashing through my chest as I wait and I hope… Come on ref, I think: send him off. I’m ready, Ref. I’m ready for it. Send him fucking off”.
(l-r) Stephen Cluxton and John Leonard pictured on the cover of Dub Sub Confidential
Leonard’s brutally honest retelling goes against every public utterance you’re likely to have heard from squad players over the years about team dynamics and morale. Cliches about the ‘importance of competition for places’ and ‘horses for courses’ are often trotted out, while all the time maintaining the most important thing is that ‘the team got the result’.
Of course, all of these things are true, and the primary duty of managers and selectors is to pick what they believe are the right players to go out and achieve the desired result. Still, it does not make the pill any easier to swallow for the player who is not selected to start the game, or worse still, to watch the full game from the bench, especially if they believe they have something to offer and are good enough to be out there.
Portugal Head Coach Fernando Santos patrols his technical area in front a few familiar disgruntled substitutes
I have not played at an elite level of sport by any means, so I can only imagine the frustrations experienced by such players and the balancing acts carried out by coaches and managers at that level to keep all players happy. I do, however, have my own experiences of standing on the line for more than enough teams down through the years to empathise with those struggles. Ultimately, I think the relative contentment of a substitute comes down to their belief in what they can offer to the team. In the words of Shakespeare’s Hamlet; “There is nothing either good or bad, thinking makes it so”.
Shakespeare’s Hamlet
In my experience, there are a number of different frames of mind in which one can observe the on-field action from the subs bench. One more palatable instance of this is when you’re part of a team that you’ve no real business being on, on the basis of your playing abilities anyway. In many ways, this can be an incredibly enjoyable experience as you can savour the success of your team, from a front row seat, without having to endure the pressure that goes with performing on the big day. The position of third choice goalkeeper at major soccer tournaments is often suggested to be one of the most coveted from certain quarters for this very reason. Irish sporting anorak @seidodge on twitter is now famed for his deep dive in profiling these “lucky” players when such competitions come around.
🎶 it’s the most wonderful time of the quadrennial 🎶
Let’s all hail the luckiest men at the World Cup – now with bonus 4th choice keepers!! https://t.co/ey2SIdCmsP
In a similar vein, there are days when for a multitude of potential reasons, you actively hope you’re not called upon by the manager. Whether this is down to a lack of confidence, maybe you’re carrying an injury or perhaps it’s just absolutely freezing and you’re too damn cold to enter the fray, it does certainly jolt a little with the conventional competitive psyche as to why you’d want to be there at all. Still as the player playing in your position goes down with an injury and the gaffer turns to assess their options, you’ve the head planted looking squarely at your boots, praying for the miraculous recovery of your stricken colleague, or that they will look elsewhere for reinforcements. Oh, how the mind operates in mysterious ways eh?
Perhaps the crux of the matter, or of this piece anyway, is the perspective of the substitute who feels that they’re good enough to start the game, or at least be on the pitch for the contest’s crucial moments. This is where the mental gymnastics and feelings of guilt start to creep in. On the one hand, you obviously want your team to do well and progress in whatever competition it is you’re competing. You’re preparing and training alongside these lads a couple of nights a week, maybe even for months prior, you clearly have a common goal – however, that doesn’t stop the potentially selfish thoughts about your own role sneaking in.
Cover of Eamon Dunphy’s incredible 1973/73 season diary ‘Only a Game?’
In his 1973/74 season memoir ‘Only a Game?’, Eamon Dunphy speaks of gleefully listening to his Millwall manager berating the starting 11 at half-time in a game in which they were 2-0 down and he wasn’t playing. He then describes feeling physically “sick” as he watched his teammates battle back to draw the game without him. Despite what they might say publicly, I’m sure that there are many who’ve been in Dunphy’s position that can empathise with his feelings on the matter.
Actively rooting against your own colleagues is not something you ever envisage yourself doing when you get involved in team sports. Though, there are points where you notice yourself taking some satisfaction in an opposing player getting the better of his marker (likely the player picked “instead” of you), maybe revelling a little in the opposition going a few points/goals ahead or as with John Leonard’s case, every fibre of your being longing for an in-game moment to actually go against your team, for your own personal benefit. Analysing that in the cold light of day, or even within the moment is difficult to reconcile in one’s mind.
Why is that the case? You find yourself considering “Am I an arsehole for thinking like this?”. Maybe you are, maybe you aren’t. Despite appreciating that only a certain number of players (15, 11, 5 etc.) can get on the pitch and a few more from the bench, the frustration of not being one of them still niggles away at you. Maybe it’s the thoughts of your family and friends watching from the stand or following the game from home. You know they’re going to ask how you got on, and you’d rather not have to explain that you actually didn’t get a run. Or perhaps it’s looking ahead to the post-match pints and celebrations. You were so close to the action, maybe there’s even a cup to be filled up. You’re pleased for the group, but you just don’t feel 100% part of it at the same time.
The UL Wolves Junior Mens Football Panel celebrate with Munster Championship Trophy
In spite of what you’ve read in the preceding few paragraphs, I do generally subscribe to the idea that everybody in the squad plays their part and deserves as many plaudits as everyone else when their team is successful. However, these words are far easier to say when you feel like you’ve made a sufficient contribution to the success, than they are to hear when you feel like you haven’t. Once more, it’s the thinking that makes it so…
Obviously, there are a number of ways that a good management team can communicate to their players the reasons why they’re not playing and what their role might be when they come off the bench to make them feel valued as part of the group. One of the most common factors highlighted by successful teams after they’ve won something is how positive the group dynamic was and just how close-knit the players felt as a unit. At the time of writing, Mikel Arteta’s Arsenal are 8 points clear at the top of the Premier League. Eddie Jones is about to lead his native Australia into the Rugby World Cup this Autumn. Should they finish those campaigns successfully, it is likely that their respective ‘Impacters’ and ‘Finishers’ will be looked on in a positive light. As somebody with enough experience in these rebranded roles, I think they’re definitely worth a shot.
The more things change, the more they stay the same. Nearly 20 months on from the last post on this site, once again it’s procrastination and running away from all the work that I’m actually supposed to be doing that’s brought me back to blogspace (EM4006 Maths Research Group look away now…). Fear not though lads, as it is in fact arithmetic and some administrators/ referees’ grasp of such matters that is the root cause of the two most high-profile Gaelic Games controversies of 2023 thus far.
It’s just over a month to the day since Kilmacud Crokes defeated Watty Graham’s Glen in the Mens All-Ireland Club Football Final in Croke Park on a scoreline of 1-11 to 1-09. It has been well documented that the Stillorgan outfit did, however, finish the game with 17 players inside the four white lines (two more than the permitted 15 of course) and the subsequent discourse on this event has been dominated by that not insignificant detail. The final play of the game, with Glen needing to engineer a goal to avoid defeat and claim their first ever All-Ireland Senior title, took place with one of the extra players standing on the goal-line.
“One Two Many?” 16 Kilmacud Crokes Players defend the final play of the 2023 All-Ireland Final
The human error of the match officials became apparent immediately after the final whistle. Instead of acting on the evidence available to them and adjudicate on whether the game needed to be replayed or if the result was to stand, the GAA stated they would not be investigating the matter unless Glen launched a formal objection of their own. Given the potential optics of being seen somehow as ‘sore losers’ or throwing away a once-in-a-lifetime chance to become All-Ireland champions, Watty Graham’s were left with an unenviable dilemma.
“What Could Have Been?” Watty Graham’s Glen Players look on following their All-Ireland Final defeat
Ultimately, nearly 72 hours after the final whistle, Glen decided to lodge an appeal to the result with the potential outcomes of being awarded the cup, having a replay ordered or a fine being imposed on Kilmacud were they to be successful. Considering that both teams had already 3 days and nights of both celebrating and commiserating done at this point, combined with the packed intercounty and intervarsity schedule, the practicalities of getting a decision and organising a replay looked less and less likely. Despite a replay being eventually ordered by the GAA’s CCCC (Central Competitions Control Committee) a full nine days after the final whistle, a counter objection came from Crokes and Glen eventually withdrew from the process stating they no longer believed “the conditions existed for a replay to be contested”.
Kilmacud Crokes Players celebrate with Andy Merrigan Cup
The second mathematical misstep may not have been as widely reported, but it’s handling at the hands of games administrators was no less egregious. In short, the UL Senior Camogie team needed to defeat Maynooth University in their final group match to draw level on points with DCU in the group phase of the Ashbourne Cup. As per the Group B table, they would also need to win by a margin of 33 points to leapfrog DCU and claim a place in Ashbourne Cup Semi-Finals. Amazingly, UL won by 34. Semi-Final place booked. Congratulations from the competition’s organisers secured.
“Amazing things happen in the Ashbourne” The congratulatory message from the official competition account now deleted
Only after the full-time whistle in Maynooth, did it become apparent that a scoreline from DCU’s first game back in November against the same opponents had been recorded incorrectly. This meant that UL’s margin of victory would have needed to be by 36 points rather than the previously communicated 33 points. Nine days after the final whistle in Maynooth, and just 72 hours out from their scheduled departure for Dublin for their semi-final clash with UCC, UL received a one-line email from the The Camogie Association’s THDC (‘Transfers, Hearings and Disciplinary Committee’). It informed them that DCU would instead be going forward in their place, based on conformation of a scoreline by a referee from a match dated 29th of November 2022.
In a statement issued by the UL panel, they revealed that an appeal had been lodged within 24 hours of receiving that email. In spite of this, the panel received notice stating that they had “failed to establish even a hearing” to plead their case and seek clarity on how the decision to eliminate them from the competition had been reached. Fast forward to Saturday (Semi-Final Day) and the UL panel travelled to UCD on their already booked bus for the match that they had been preparing for since their victory in Maynooth. Ironically, and rather cruelly in fact, they arrived at the Belfield venue to see their player profiles still included in the competition programme, only emphasising how late the decision to eliminate them had been made.
The UL Ashbourne Panel watch on at in Belfield as the Ashbourne Cup Semi-Final takes place without them
Right before the throw-in of the day’s second semi-final between UCC and DCU, the players donned their matchday jerseys and climbed onto the surrounding fence of Dave Billings Park in a powerful, silent show of strength against their treatment. Despite travelling to Dublin in search of answers, the squad expressed disappointment that nobody from the CCAO (Third Level Camogie Association) came to speak to them or offer any explanation. The competition’s official account tweeted the below short statement later that evening:
CCAO Statement
The three main Gaelic Games associations have done tremendous marketing and promotional work in conjunction with commercial partners over the last number of years. Notwithstanding their own ongoing GAA related scandal… AIB’s #TheToughest campaign has undoubtedly raised the profile of the club championships to new heights using taglines such as “Tough Can’t Quit” and “Even when the crowd is small, the support is huge”. Similarly, Liberty Insurance partnered with the Camogie Association to highlight how the sport makes its players “Ready for the Real World” developing attributes such as resilience, strength and leadership, all the while seeing attendances consistently rise for its flagship events such as the All-Ireland Semi-Finals and indeed Finals. Lidl’s “Serious Athletes Deserve Serious Support” as well as significant investment targeted at LGFA clubs and supporters around the country has yielded even greater numbers in terms of intercounty final crowds along with increased playing numbers in at underage level.
However, it is these very initiatives and grand statements that make such decisions, or a lack thereof in the case of the aforementioned controversies, all the more galling to players and supporters. Outside the white heat of battle, most rational people will understand and accept that human beings make mistakes. What is not acceptable though is the complete abdication of responsibility on behalf of the respective associations, when it comes to acknowledging and dealing with those mistakes head on once they are made. It is far easier to extol the virtues of our amateur athletes and volunteer coaches in a publicity push than it is to actually exhibit that purported toughness, resilience, strength and leadership when it comes to making difficult choices in the best interests those athletes and coaches.
Few would argue with the right of teams to air their grievances regarding any potential injustice that they may have suffered as DCU and Kilmacud Crokes did in their respective scenarios. Though what I’m sure many would hope, is that the administrators responsible for dealing with such appeals and grievances would do so in a manner that is decisive, transparent and maintains the principle of fairness to all parties involved throughout. The furore surrounding DCU in their progression to the semi-final cannot have helped in their preparations for the game itself. Similarly, the 2023 All-Ireland Club Mens Football Final will always be associated with the 17 players Kilmacud Crokes had on the pitch at the end, regardless of how well they had played in the preceding 63 minutes.
Cometh the hour (+ET), cometh Róisín McCormack!What a way to win your first ever @electricireland@3rdLevelCamogie Ashbourne Cup title! Shades of the last final to be won in the competition with ET required as Trish Jackman nailed a late free for WIT back in 2013. Congrats @TUDpic.twitter.com/qtD5XfUKGM
Once the ball was thrown in Belfield a fortnight ago, the game that took place between DCU and UCC was incredible. In a match that ebbed and flowed throughout, UCC prevailed after extra-time. The following day, the final also went to extra-time with Róisín McCormack’s last minute free handing TU Dublin their first ever Ashbourne Cup crown. Both Mens Club Finals in 2022 were also decided by last minute goals and were neither short on drama nor skill levels of the highest quality. We are so lucky in Gaelic Games to have such brilliant ambassadors and talented purveyors of our four codes. The quality of fare that they serve up will promote itself with the right backing and effective organisation. Serious athletes deserve serious support. It’s time those charged with administering our games started giving it to them.
As Paul Cunningham’s tweet of a demolition crew at work on the site of Leisureplex Stillorgan flashed up on my Twitter feed a couple of weeks ago, I was overcome by a palpable sense of loss. To some, the clearing of space, making way for the construction of residential accommodation in a Dublin suburb during a housing crisis would be cause for celebration, but judging by the replies and reaction to Paul’s tweet, I certainly wasn’t the only one moved by the news. Scrolling through the reflective anecdotes and tales left below the line provoked thoughts of why events such as these, evoke such emotional responses in people and what is it exactly that we “mourn” when we lament the loss of, what could rather crudely be described as mere bricks and mortar?
Originally built in 1963 as the ‘Stillorgan Bowl’, the complex opened as the first bowling alley in the country at the time. Only in later years after its rebranding as Leisureplex Stillorgan, did this particular writer (and many readers of this post I’m sure) become acquainted with the place. For so many children of the borough, an invite to a primary school birthday party at Leisureplex’s ‘The Zoo’ was the hottest ticket in town. As party hosts got older, the viennetta birthday cake and free helium balloons delivered by Plexy the Dinosaur were soon replaced by the far cooler combination of bowling and quasar.
l-r: Viennetta ‘Cake’ and Plexy the Dinosaur
If you were a sufficiently mad bastard, you more than likely went along to the Spin teenage discos at the venue as a 12 year-old, however, for those not brazen enough to try their luck there, the Stillorgan joint still had plenty to offer as one progressed into their adolescent years and beyond. Whether it be family days out, a first date or skulling cans of premium lager on BYOB nights, while ending in ignominy on occasion, such events only served to enhance the cultural significance of this institution on our short lives.
That’s before you even get to the fact that the site was a favoured haunt of US rock icon Bruce Springsteen during his visits to Ireland, and while operating 24 hours during the 00’s, the bowling alley played host to some of the more hilarious tenpin tussles as revellers from the neighbouring Bondi Beach nightclub, now also demolished, staggered across the road in the small hours of the morning seeking to extract that last bit of craic from their night out.
‘The Boss’ – Bruce Springsteen and his entourage arrive at Leisureplex on one of his visits to Ireland
So why the grief? In many ways the answer is obvious. So many of the aforementioned memories provide a lens through which to look back on our childhoods and adolescence at various points along the line. Nostalgia is defined in the Oxford Dictionary as “the sentimental longing for the past”, and it’s perfectly understandable how the levelling of Leisureplex would elicit such a longing in anybody who can connect memories of their youth to the place. Nostalgia and the human memory are funny things though.
Plexy mixing with fans at my brother’s 4th birthday party (2002)
Up until the turn of the last century, Nostalgia was still being classified as a “mentally compulsive disorder” in some quarters, having been initially deemed “a neurological disease of essentially demonic cause” in the 17th century by Swiss military doctor, Johannes Hofer. The notion of nostalgia as some kind of mental illness has been dispelled, with more recent studies going as far as to show that nostalgia can in fact be effective in counteracting loneliness, boredom and anxiety as well as making people feel more optimistic about the future when they think and speak fondly of their past.
‘The Father of Nostalgia’ – Johannes Hofer
However, when experiencing nostalgia, it is important to be aware of the cognitive phenomenon of “rosy retrospection” which arouses memories of the past in a more favourable light. The human memory can be selective, and we tend to edit it to our advantage at times. What our memory selectively ignores in these instances, as we wistfully reminisce about the good aul’ days in Stillorgan, are being hit in the face by a salty cocktail sausage during a mid-meal food fight, that most parties invariably ended up with Plexy getting the shite kicked out of him by those in attendance, while on further reflection, the only thing I can really recall about playing quasar is suffering the same fate as poor Plexy, except in laser-form. Of course, there was also that robotic repetition of “Return to Energiser” ringing in your ears throughout.
‘Return to Energiser’ – The Quasar Arena at Leisureplex Stillorgan
Also forgotten is the teenage angst that comes with the territory when socialising at that age, as are the many nights where an over-indulgence on the cheap hooch results in the gorgeous, giddy promise of a night on the town giving way to scraps with bouncers and teary-eyed Zaytoon kebabs.
l-r: Bouncer breaks up fight and Zaytoon, Camden Street
Is there a reason why memories from this particular period of our lives stir such intense feelings of nostalgia and rosy retrospection? The answer is yes. The human brain undergoes a massive reorganisation between the ages of 12 and 25. During this period, the limbic system, which is the part of the brain responsible for processing emotion, is hypersensitive. The rational areas of the brain, such as the prefrontal cortex, which serve the function of controlling one’s emotions and impulses, develop much later in adolescence than their limbic counterparts. Therefore, it makes sense that we attach so much meaning to relationships and react so emotionally to events during these formative years.
For example, it’s why news of bands such as Westlife and One Direction breaking up leave teenage girls and boys alike, across the globe in tears. It also goes some way to explaining why we mourn the deaths of public figures, such as Kobe Bryant and Jack Charlton, despite never having known them personally during their lifetime. Even though it is still possible to dance the night away to the Westlife megamix, enjoy countless compilations of Kobe’s fadeaway on YouTube, or bask in the glory of Italia ’90 from the Reeling in the Years montage, the mere sight or sound of these things only serves to remind us of the inextricable link between those memories and our respective identities. Such snapshots briefly transport us back to these times, allowing us to remember where we were, how we felt and who we wanted to become during these particular moments.
l-r: Kobe Bryant and Jack Charton
So, as these bastions of our early years begin to exit stage left, we are reminded that their contributions to our lives are now part of the past, and therefore, so too is our youth. Ultimately, it is a realisation that things will never quite be the same again.
The irony of writing such a piece as a 24 year-old is not lost on me. Maybe it’s my silver jubilee birthday on the horizon in November, or it could have something to do with spending the last year trying to convince my Gen-Z college housemates that I am not in fact a total codger. Either way, the news of Plexy and crew’s departure from their Stillorgan home hit me harder than expected.
Clockwise l-r: Club 92 dancefloor, Clonkeen pitches, The Wezz Disco Guarantee and Vanilla Nightblub interior.
As we face into the future, in the absence of southside institutions such as Club 92, the Clonkeen pitches, Vanilla and Wezz to light the way for the generations to follow, it’s only natural to feel that sense of loss. In reality, as I’ve already alluded to, our brains are chemically wired that way. Nonetheless, there are always reasons for optimism, and indulging ourselves in a bit of nostalgia every so often is clinically proven to enhance such feelings of hope for the future. In the immortal words of Frank Sinatra, “The best is yet to come”. RIP Plexy – Thanks for the Memories.
They say a week is a long time in politics, but what is the equivalent in blogspace? In the 10 or so months since this blog half-heartedly predicted a Fianna Fáil-Green Party government in last February’s General Election, it’s fair to say that quite a lot has happened. That potentially deadly virus in Wuhan turned out to be a little more problematic than many anticipated, Donald Trump is soon to be a mere West Clare hotelier once more, and the Dubs are still Kings and Queens of the football world. Some things never change.
On a personal note, significant change has also been afoot. In September, I decided to trade in my white shirt and lanyard for some skinny trackies and a one-way ticket to the University of Limerick to “live the dream” one more time, training to become a PE teacher in the process. The allure of guilt-free, midweek pints (of Rock Shandy) and the months of June, July and August on holidays proved just too much for the 7.27am 84X and the preparation of financial statements.
So, as the shutter comes down on my first semester as a mature student undergraduate, what has the experience been like? If you’re considering going down a similar route yourself, what can you expect? In the next couple of paragraphs, I am going to channel my inner Ned Bigby, and detail some of my own experiences as well as a few potential pitfalls that await the budding mature student on their return to full-time education.
(l-r) Moze, Ned and Cookie from 2000s American Sitcom; Ned’s Declassified School Survival Guide
Hello There, Fellow Kids
One of the first things you notice on your maiden visit to campus is how young everybody walking around the place is. To this 24-year-old Fresher, everybody looks like a secondary school student at an Open Day. The situation doesn’t get a whole lot better as you begin to meet your housemates and the people in your course, where the swapping of Snapchat and Instagram usernames begins. The prevalence of ’01’, ‘02’ and even ‘03’ (!) at the end of those usernames would make you feel very old indeed.
Accurate representation of me on my first day
As you can imagine, being “down with the kids” is therefore, pretty crucial to fitting in and befriending your new Post-Millennial mates. Knowing your VSCOs from your Instagrams will stand you in good stead, while the etiquette and politics around your inclusion in someone’s private Snapchat story will all come in good time. Whatever you do, just be sure not to ask anyone for their phone number to set up a class WhatsApp group. WhatsApp is only used by this crowd for texting their parents and grandparents, and for “formal group chats” Any aspiring mature student would do well to remember this.
VSCO vs WhatsApp
As anybody of a Tuborg Rovers persuasion will know only too well, there’s a fine line between “Puss” and “Rags”. For those who haven’t got a clue what I’m talking about, fear not. Everybody has some experience of colloquialisms and slang that they only hear or use around certain people. Your new college environment is going to be no different. Whether it’s “noting, highlighting and underlining” some important information or salacious goss, or congratulating a housemate on their romantic success with a shout of “Yeow”. You dare not use a colloquialism inappropriately, or out of place without risking temporary social pariah status. “Low-key, high-key” buzzing for the night ahead? Absolutely. Never “High-key, low-key”. Never.
Housemates
For me, having commuted to college throughout my years in DCU, moving down to Limerick also meant living away from home for the first time. Moving away from the Pale is a daunting enough experience in itself, especially not having Mammy there to cook and clean up after you. That’s before you even consider the complete lottery that is campus accommodation housemate allocations.
For the most part, your new domestic comrades will be in the same position as yourself, bright-eyed and eager to make friends, but there are a few horror stories out there. Depending on your luck, they can make or break the whole experience. In the vast majority of cases, these will be the first friends you’re likely to make in college, and in this year of all years, with all the COVID-related visitor restrictions, it’s particularly important that you at least have a functioning relationship with them. Even if none of them are old enough to remember when Robbie stuck the ball past Kahn in Ibaraki.
Robbie Keane celebrates his equaliser in the 2002 World Cup Group Stage game vs Germany
The best advice I got on the food preparation front was for cooking meat in the oven; “200°C for 20 minutes and you won’t go far wrong”. We’ve managed to get through until Christmas without giving anyone food poisoning. So far, so good. Thankfully, everybody in the house is relatively self-sufficient in the cooking stakes, and for the most part, they strike the right balance on food property rights. The hammer and sickle that adorns the main wall of the kitchen/front room is there for a reason.
It is when it comes to keeping the place clean and tidy, that the hastily arranged Marxist foundations of the house-share begin to crack. The sink is often a great place to find dirty dishes and cutlery, if washing up is your thing. A discussion on traditional gender stereotypes elicited one of the quotes of the semester; “I do have a feminine side, sure I just cleaned my toilet this morning”, solidifying the position of article 41.2 of Bunreacht na hÉireann on the place of the woman in the home for another generation at least. While on another occasion, the defence offered for not replacing a bin bag after the original was removed, was the avoidance of a “demarcation dispute”, such is the regularity with which this writer is left that responsibility. A true champion of the working man.
In summary, be prepared to share a bit more of the cleaning burden if you don’t want to live all your college life in squalor.
The residents of 22 Holly House, pictured at the ‘Dromroe Debs’ 2020
Fashion
In the words of Oscar Wilde, “You can never be overdressed or overeducated”. If the last 12 weeks are anything to go by, there’s no danger of this year’s Holly House residents proving him wrong. Not a whole lot has changed since my first go at being a fresher all the way back in 2015. You’ll be delighted (or disgusted) to hear skinny trackies and half-zips are still very much a thing. O’Neills shorts are also back, that’s if they ever even went away. The role played by Paul Mescal and Normal People in this renaissance is debatable. It might just be a culchie thing… who knows? Long may it continue is all I’ll say.
“It’s a vibe” – Normal People’s Paul Mescal models his Maynooth GAA shorts in London this summer.
One major culture shock to the unsuspecting millennial is the distinct lack of unripped jeans on show. Whether it’s a few pints in the Stables or a “dress up” night in, some of these lads look like they’ve been kicked up and down River Island, the cut of them. Whatever about the torn skinny jeans, the real must have accessory for any self-respecting, modern day college student is a pair of sliders. Not going to lie, I’d say I’d have called them flip-flops in 2015, but they’re incredibly comfortable to wear around the gaff and it’s socially acceptable, if not advisable, to wear them with socks. I purchased a pair at the end of Week 1, and I haven’t looked back since. Low-key, high-key absolutely essential.
‘The Holy Trinity’ – Ripped Jeans, Sliders and O’Neills shorts
Budgeting
Unfortunately, despite living in the era of “free fees” where it still costs €3,000 a year to go to college, before you even think about looking for somewhere to live, all of this craic and high jinx doesn’t come for nothing. “No mon’ no fun”. Whether it’s a part-time job, a very generous relative or the proceeds of crime, the money has to come from somewhere. And once you’ve sourced “the monies”, you’ve got to be clever and stretch those funds as far as possible.
Cans of Galahad and bottles of Tamova are very much the currency down here, and in many ways that is right and proper. The legendary tales of students of yesteryear surviving solely on pot noodles haven’t quite been in evidence just yet, though there have been a couple of Bank of Ireland apps showing single figure balances. As a result, price and proximity are the primary considerations when choosing the location for the weekly food shop, putting a certain German discount retailer in pole position.
‘Legal Tender’
Now as a mature student, it might be a mix of enjoying the finer things in life, supporting Irish or a hint of snobbery that leads you to be a bit more discerning in your choice of supermarket. Supervalu in Castletroy is possibly the nicest one in the country and their organic spaghetti is second to none. Expect the bit of judgement from your younger peers and embrace it. We all need a bit of comfort and indulgence now and again.
Understandably, the frugality isn’t reserved for just grub. Spotify premium and paying to do your own washing are still considered to be luxuries. So, when one of the young lads gets on the speaker, be prepared for intermittent ‘HAYU’ ads on Spotify unless of course, the DJ went to private school. In such a case, the bill for the ad-free music is probably being footed by an Irish hospitality conglomerate.
Night Life
For the first two and half weeks of the semester, county Limerick was in Level 2 of the country’s ‘National Framework for living with COVID’. This meant ‘wet pubs’ were allowed to open and gave us a sample of what Limerick city has to offer. By ‘sample’, I of course mean returning every chance we got, to the only place that’d take us, Molly Malone’s Bar and Restaurant. It was great to get the chance to pretend the pandemic just wasn’t a thing for a few hours, even if the scenes of singsongs on the bus into town were a tad dystopian with everybody masked up. Unfortunately, the imposition of Level 3, and Level 5 shortly after, put paid to much of the extra-curricular activity.
‘The Wheels on the bus go round and round’ – Masked singsongs on the bus? Very 2020
Level 5 saw the reintroduction into my life of the North American frat house staple, Beer Pong. A game that is much maligned in many quarters, but with restrictions on visitors and nowhere else to be going, it successfully performs the functions of sufficiently oiling its participants, and getting the competitive juices flowing.
Individual house rules will dictate whether the ball must bounce once on the table or not, to be deemed a valid attempt. Some knowledge of cup formations such as a “diamond”, “one-and-one” or a “battleship” is useful, but not essential. Your opponent(s) won’t be long, or shy in putting you straight. You’ll also develop a newfound appreciation for the role of the ‘towel technician’, the game’s unsung hero, who ensures the ball is kept dry and maintains the flow of the game with minimum fuss. However, if you only take one thing from this paragraph, make sure you keep your elbow behind the table at all times when throwing, unless you want to start World War III.
Some ‘Towel Technicians’ flat to the boards
The lifting of Level 5 restrictions, and the reopening of pubs and restaurants at the start of December, allowed for some more meaningful Christmas celebrations. UL Christmas Day 2020 was a thoroughly enjoyable experience, filled with seasonal joy and merriment, that did not lack in drama. Truth be told, it was refreshing to return to the role of “babysitter” for the first night in quite some time.
For the most part, people practiced moderation in their alcohol consumption, however, there is always a few who overindulge. As is generally the case in such a situation, there are a few immediately recognisable stages to this process.
The innocence and invincibility of youth is on full display as lads go that bit too heavy on their eastern European, premium lager of choice, free from the pending interrogation from Mammy when they get home. Sadly, this performance is only a prelude to the indignance of seeing their Turkey and Ham dinner once again. Chunder fest.
Of course, this is followed by the martyrdom and insistence on cleaning up (rearranging in reality) their own mess, before eventually acquiescing and allowing the grownups to finish the job properly. Being the ‘adult in the room’ as it were, such carry on would fill you with disgust and pride in equal measure. As Elton John says; “The Circle of Life”.
‘Man down’
‘The Books’ – College Itself
If you were looking for a break from all the Zoom, Skype and Microsoft Teams meetings this pandemic has got us so well acquainted with, then the academic year of 2020-21 was not the year to return to full-time education. Barring two wonderful Mondays on campus in Weeks 7 and 10 respectively, all lectures and tutorials have been either recorded or live on the aforementioned platforms. Everybody’s favourite three words of 2020, “You’re on mute”, are still alive and kicking, while there is the added dimension of more live, on-camera interactions than this former accounting trainee was exposed to in the home office.
‘The Virtual Waiting Room’
Despite all their predicted leaving cert points and Snapchat “vlogs”, you will find a certain reluctance among your new classmates to turn on their mics and engage with lecturers unless specifically prompted. As with the bins earlier, be prepared the shoulder more of the burden in the spokesperson stakes if you want to avoid awkward, protracted, virtual silences. More pressingly perhaps, the added visual component of the online classroom also brings with it some potential perils. For example, one of your less technologically literate housemates walking into your live Zoom tutorial half-naked. A rather mortifying experience for all involved. Best avoided by locking your bedroom door in advance of these classes.
One major positive of the COVID protocols is the requirement to pre-book your study space in the library before you visit. Especially as you get into the latter weeks of the semester, this spares students the indignity of the mid-morning ‘walk of shame’ around the building in search of a seat. Of course, the odd time there is somebody incorrectly occupying your assigned seat, but this minor inconvenience is so much more preferable to experiencing the judgemental smugness of those who’ve been there since opening time to claim their study spot for the day. You would miss the ‘Shush Lady’ all the same.
Mol an Óige agus Tiocfaidh Sí
As I have already alluded to, the difference in age between you and your classmates is one of the biggest challenges for any mature student returning to complete an undergraduate degree. This year’s Leaving Cert class and their peers were often vilified in much of the current affairs commentary over the past year, for their roles in the spreading/prevention of infection. The context missing from a lot of that criticism was an acknowledgement of how much this cohort in particular, lost out on. From rites of passage such as the Debs and graduation from secondary school to the absolute savaging of the way they socialise. Perhaps coloured by this type of analysis, I was pleasantly surprised at just how conscientious and appreciative my housemates and classmates were, of the seriousness of the situation with regards to the pandemic.
The 22 Holly House Crew alongside the ‘COVID 19 Communal Living Guidelines’
At the risk of getting overly mushy, they were by no means the worst crew to start out my second college journey with, and as evidenced by some of the following quotes, we might be able to learn a thing or two from them along the way as well.
Heard out of context in Week 2; “Whether you’re texting him, shifting him or riding him, just mind yourself”. Incredibly sound advice from one so young, and words we can all aspire to live by. Look after number one first and foremost.
Striking a slightly less conventional note, apparently those from an especially landlocked county in Ireland are in fact their own race; “I’m from Laois, I can be as racist as I want”. Disrespect a county board official though? A different story altogether.
Former Laois hurling manager, Eddie Brennan
Finally, after a typically manic and stressful Week 12 spent finishing assignments at the eleventh hour and swotting for final exams, various iterations of “Next semester, I’m going to have my shit together” rang around Holly House. The innocence of youth eh? Some things never change.
So, in a year like no other, it’s been a semester like no other. No matter what metric you want to use, it’s impossible for me to argue it’s been anything other than an unqualified success. Here’s to the next seven!
“I’ve always said that the election should happen at the best time for the country, now is that time”. I’m sure many of the 516 declared Dáil hopefuls questioned that wisdom, as Leo Varadkar called the first Saturday General Election in the history of the state, and they faced the prospect of spending the coldest month of the year on the campaign trail. With so much focus on electoral events and political goings on across the Irish Sea in recent years, electoral aficionados and psephologists on these shores finally have a domestic ballot to get their teeth into.
Taoiseach Leo Varadkar calls General Election 2020
Considering its level of prominence throughout 2019, Brexit hasn’t been as much of a factor for voters so far in this campaign. Instead, the most prominent and consistent talking points thus far have been Housing and Health, interspersed with a bizarre level of Senior Hurling chat for this time of year. The Taoiseach was at pains to stress the benefits of his decision to send the country to the polls at the weekend. With the inconvenience of schools having to close on a weekday avoided, working parents won’t have to take time off work, lose a day’s income, or face additional childcare costs. “The people who get up in the morning” boxed off. Students and those getting up in the morning to work away from home weren’t forgotten either, now afforded the opportunity to come home for the weekend and cast their votes. With the 8th of February a matter of hours away, what sort of impact the break from tradition will have on voter turnout remains to be seen, though after nearly four weeks of campaigning and no less than seven opinion polls since the election was called, we do have some idea of who the key players are, and how the 33rd Dáil might look this time next week.
Fine Gael
The largest party in Dáil Éireann after the last two elections, Fine Gael has headed up both coalition and minority governments in that time with Enda Kenny leading the party and country until June 2017, before being succeeded by Leo Varadkar. In the vast majority of opinion polls carried out during Varadkar’s time in office, the party has been the largest in the country. Allegations of fraud and scandal surrounding TDs Dara Murphy, Maria Bailey and Alan Farrell, while creating national headlines, did little to damage Fine Gael’s impressive polling figures. It was only in the first poll after the election was called, that support for the party plummeted from 27% to 20%, where it has remained relatively steady since then. They now lie in third place in the polls less 24 hours out from election day. Possibly influenced by that poll position, their strategy has been an odd mixture of contrition, targeted attacks on Fianna Fáil and Sinn Féin and some disastrously memeable social media content.
(left to right, Dara Murphy, Maria Bailey and Alan Farrell TD)
Eoghan Murphy, Paschal Donohoe and Varadkar himself have all qualified their praise of the government’s record on Housing and Health at various stages of the campaign, with the phrase “I know it’s not enough”, in an appeal to be given more time to finish what they’ve started. Keep the Recovery Going 2.0 anybody? Every so often the contrition is interrupted, namely by the Taoiseach himself, in order to deliver some fairly targeted personal jibes at Micheál Martin. The first leaders’ debate saw the more thinly-veiled assertion that Martin’s constituency rival, Simon Coveney, was the finest politician Cork ever produced, before Varadkar’s most recent claim, that returning Fianna Fáil to government, with Martin as Taoiseach would be like “asking John Delaney to take over the FAI again”. Sinn Féin haven’t got off the hook in this regard either with the party’s radical tax proposals compared to previous offerings in East Germany and the oft cited, “failed socialist state” of Venezuela. The aforementioned Coveney, along with the rest of his cabinet colleagues, have also been steadfast in their refusal to entertain the idea of forming a coalition government with Sinn Féin, most notably in that now infamous Twitter video, latched onto by rival parties and meme-makers alike, resulting in some rather hilarious content and a lot of embarrassment for Fine Gael.
I will never go into government with Sinn Féin. I asked my team if they would and they answered unequivocally.
One of the perceived strengths of the outgoing government was its handling of Brexit, which annoyingly for them just hasn’t captured the imagination of voters. With approximately 20% of popular support and lying in third position in the opinion polls, the party is on the defensive. Eoghan Murphy’s record as Housing Minister, the outgoing Ceann Cohmairle’s seat in Dún Laoghaire and murmurings of difficulties for Paschal Donohoe and Noel Rock in Dublin Central and Dublin North-West, suggest Fine Gael is in survival mode in the capital. There has also been some commentary about the party’s lack of focus on rural issues over the last month and their time in government. Garda stations around the country on reduced hours or remaining shut altogether, the prospect of a carbon tax and the failure to effectively implement the National Broadband Plan could hurt them badly in rural constituencies. On a bad day, they could be left with a seat total in the low 30s, leaving them very much on the outside looking in when it comes to government formation.
Fianna Fáil
Brand Fianna Fáil has undergone a phenomenal transformation over the course of the last nine years. Just ask the FAI delegate, who at last December’s AGM, argued that the resurgence of the former “toxic brand” in recent years could act as a beacon of hope to the country’s debt-ridden and disgraced football governing body. After the first Sunday Times opinion poll of the campaign had the party at 32%, the @BustToBoom twitter account was in overdrive, with plenty of noughties nostalgia, the return of the SSIA and talk of tents at the Galway races. In reality, this might have been a bit of an overstatement, and as some might argue, unlike previous iterations of the party, nobody in HQ was getting too carried away. In the opinion polls since then, party support has been around the 23/24% mark, vying with Sinn Féin to be classed as the most popular party in the country. The man behind this revival? Micheál Martin.
“This is a one-way service to BACKISTAN”
Having opened his tenure as party leader with an unequivocal apology to the nation on behalf of Fianna Fáil for the mistakes it made while in Government, as well as personally advocating for a yes vote in both the Marriage Equality and Eigth Amendment referenda, allowing a free vote within his own party for the latter, it’s fair to say Martin has done a lot of the heavy lifting when it comes to regaining public trust. The party’s showing in the polls would appear to suggest it’s come away relatively unscathed from providing the outgoing Fine Gael-Independent government with “Confidence and Supply”, though it has left them vulnerable to criticism from the left, on the claim that they might hold a degree of responsibility for some the previous government’s shortcomings.
Like Fine Gael, Fianna Fáil have repeatedly ruled out the notion of doing business with Sinn Féin in forming the next government. Instead, on the subject of potential coalition partners, Micheál Martin has expressed his preference to do business with, in his own words “centre ground TDs from parties like Labour and the Greens”. A move towards the left, with an ambitious social housing building plan of nearly 200,000 homes over the course of five years and (a Jack Chambers meltdown notwithstanding) a reasonably successful accentuation of the party’s ‘Green’ credentials, might well have done enough to tempt both parties to the negotiating table, should the numbers be there. For such a coalition to come to fruition, the 50-seat barrier must be broken. With only five outgoing TDs in Dublin and strong local election performances throughout the capital last summer, there is huge scope for growth here with strong chances of gains in Dún Laoghaire, Dublin North-West and Rathdown. Cathal Crowe looks good for a seat gain in Clare and if attainable third seats in Laois-Offaly and Carlow-Kilkenny are achieved, Micheál Martin might just find a Sinn Féin-free path to the government benches.
Sinn Féin
If Fianna Fáil’s transformation over the last nine years has been phenomenal, the resurrection of Sinn Féin in the nine months since the Local and European elections has been Lazarus-like. Having lost almost half of its seats on local councils throughout the country and two of its three MEPs, it was very much back to the drawing board. Mary Lou McDonald has played a blinder for large parts of this campaign. Having languished well behind the two main parties in the polls for much of 2019, the party has been catapulted to the top of the opinion polls for the first time in its history, perhaps aided somewhat by the government’s ill-advised RIC commemoration announcement in January, but certainly reflective of the desire for a break from the status quo from almost a quarter of the electorate. So how has Mary Lou and the party achieved this?
In producing one of the most ambitious and radical manifestos in this campaign, which promises to build 100,000 social and affordable homes, abolish third level fees and introduce free GP care for all, they set their stall out early. Their strategy since then has also been very clear, to saturate the airwaves and media with their top performers to get the message out and to try to use the attacks from both Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael to their advantage. With Eoin Ó Broin on Housing, Louise O’Reilly on Health and Pearse Doherty on Finance, this strong, fresh and dynamic trio of spokespeople can talk Housing, Health and Finance ‘til the cows come home and have been more than capable of taking their counterparts from rival parties to task on the national stage. Mary Lou has also distinguished herself as one those ‘top performers’ throughout the campaign, gaining a lot a traction in dubbing Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael, “Tweedledee and Tweedledum” as well as successfully arguing her way onto Tuesday’s Prime Time leaders’ debate, having repeatedly claimed to be “shut out” by the other two main parties and sections of the media. Given that her party is only fielding 42 candidates in total, many would argue that she had no place taking part in the debate, initially billed as a “head-to-head” between the two would-be Taoisigh. Others might argue that the figure of 25% says otherwise.
“Top Performers” (Clockwise l-r) Mary Lou McDonald TD, Eoin Ó Broin TD, Louise O’Reilly TD and Pearse Doherty TD
Despite the many reasons for optimism, there are also some causes for concern. Sinn Féin’s finance minister in Northern Ireland, Conor Murphy’s comments in 2007 after the brutal murder of 21-year-old Paul Quinn have brought the party’s historic links to the IRA back into the spotlight. In her weakest moment of Tuesday’s debate, Mary Lou was forced to do a U-turn only 24 hours after denying the severity of Murphy’s 2007 comments in an interview with Bryan Dobson. Concerns also remain in some quarters over the level of control that unelected members of the party’s Ard Chomhairle have in day-to-day policy decisions. A number of councillors have also left the party amid disputes over bullying allegations in recent years. From a purely arithmetic point of view, the party may find it difficult to break the 30-seat barrier, in spite of its impressive poll standing. The decision to drop second candidates from constituency tickets on the back of poor local election performances now looks unwise, but depending on the performance of Tweedledee and Tweedledum, Mary Lou could yet play a significant role as a kingmaker.
Conor Murphy MLA (left) and murder victim, Paul Quinn (right)
Green Party
With the climate crisis such a pressing issue worldwide and so many Green Party councillors and MEPs elected last May, you would have been forgiven for believing the “Green Wave” would carry a surge of climate activists led by Eamon Ryan into the 33rd Dáil. However, the party has stagnated at around 10% support nationally. Prior to the calling of this election, much of the talk among political correspondents and strategists surrounded the potential for the Green Party to woo middle class Fine Gael voters and take some seats on the back of support from that demographic. While that would appear to be materialising in Dublin and some other urban constituencies, much of the groundswell for change seems to have benefitted Sinn Féin in this particular campaign.
Much has been made of the party’s migration towards the left since their time in government. While the Greens always supported a carbon tax of some description, their manifesto this time around includes proposals for a system of Universal Basic Income, free public transport for students and an innovative solution to the housing crisis in the form of the “Cost Rental Model”, borrowed from mainland European cities such as Vienna. It is however, the rural-urban divide that’s been largely to blame for their stagnation in the polls as the carbon tax and maybe more importantly, the party position on the reduction in the size of the suckler herd have not played well with those working in the agricultural sector.
Eamon Ryan TD (left), All-Ireland Suckler Cow and Calf (right)
Still, the “Green Wave” from last May’s local elections should be enough for the party to make gains in Dún Laoghaire and Dublin West through Ossian Smyth and Roderic O’Gorman. There are also opportunities in a number of other ‘urban’ constituencies like Kildare North, Cork South-Central, Waterford and Wicklow. Saoirse McHugh is possibly their best hope of a ‘rural’ breakthrough. The Mayo candidate burst onto the national stage in last year’s European Parliament elections, getting over 50,000 first preference votes in the Midlands-North-West constituency. Already touted as Ireland’s answer to Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, and as the Green Party’s own Princess Margaret during this election, she has publicly disagreed with her party’s position on the carbon tax and has emphasised the need for “rural Greens” to make their voices heard. Should she break the Fine Gael-Fianna Fáil duopoly in Mayo over the course of the weekend, the party could be on the way to returning as many as 15 TDs to Leinster House. With Eamon Ryan’s willingness to talk to anybody with an interest in a green agenda, it’s very hard not to see the party having a significant say in the makeup of the next government.
After being decimated as the outgoing government’s junior coalition partner last time out, the party opted for experience over youth in backing Brendan Howlin to succeed Joan Burton as leader of the party, overlooking the fresher, and arguably more exciting alternatives of Alan Kelly and Seán Sherlock in the process. Kelly, a representative for Tipperary, is probably most famous on a national level for his “power is a drug” quotes from a number of years back. He mooted a further leadership challenge during the summer of 2018, citing Howlin’s “failure to turn the ship around” in his two and a half years of leadership, as his motivation for doing so. Again, a lack of support for the idea within the parliamentary party put paid to his leadership ambitions, and the party has presented a united front since then with Kelly impressing in his roles as party Health spokesperson and Vice-Chair of the Public Accounts Committee.
Out with the old, in with the new? Brendan Howlin TD (left), Alan Kelly TD (right)
It’s hard to argue with Kelly’s assertion that Howlin has failed to make any headway in altering public opinion towards the party, with its 5% support in the most recent RedC poll even lower than the disastrous 6.6% share of the national vote four years ago, that delivered the party’s joint-worst Dáil return in history. With a simple campaign message of “Build Homes and Fix Health”, Brendan Howlin has more than held his own in the two televised debates involving the leaders of the other six main parties, advocating a rent freeze, building 80,000 social homes on public land and a “Liveable Communities” project designed to ease pressure on those living in the commuter belt. While those progressive messages might have resonated with many people beyond that 5% core of Labour Party support, the very presence of the older guard of Howlin, Burton and Jan O’Sullivan, incredible servants to the party though they have been, leaves them open to criticism of the party’s shortcomings in the last government, and goes some way to explaining the lack of movement in that 5% figure over the last four years.
In saying all of that, it’s not all doom and gloom for Labour in this campaign, with a couple of strong opportunities to build on its current haul of seven seats. Aodhán Ó Ríordáin in Dublin Bay North and Ged Nash in Louth, both enjoy strong national profiles and are the party’s main hopes of seat gains, with the seat of the retiring Willie Penrose in Longford-Westmeath almost certainly lost, despite the best efforts of Alan Mangan. Rebecca Moynihan and Kevin Humphreys hold outside chances of claiming final seats in the capital, while Mark Wall could also go close Kildare South. A return of 8 seats is entirely possible and would mark a successful campaign for Howlin. Might the vastly experienced legislator be tempted for one last hurrah in the corridors of power if the numbers and Micheál Martin presented such an opportunity?
What’s Next?
Support for independents and other parties not mentioned above has been in and around the 20% mark over the course of the campaign’s seven opinion polls. That’s exactly a fifth of the electorate. While it’s very hard to extrapolate from national poll figures to predict how individual independents will fare in a given constituency, some of these candidates will almost certainly have role to play when it comes to the formation of a government, with the numbers so tight. The Social Democrats under Catherine Murphy and Róisín Shortall could return as many as five TDs with strong chances in Dublin Central, Dublin Bay North and Galway West. Given their proximity to Labour and the Greens on the political spectrum, a strong performance from them could see a progressive alliance between those three parties to form a coalition government with Fianna Fáil. We already know that’s the coalition option Micheál Martin would prefer.
Independent candidates like Michael Healy-Rae in Kerry and Michael Lowry in Tipperary can be relatively assured of retaining their seats, however it will only be as an option of last resort if either of those men end up at the negotiating table. Independents from the Fianna Fáil “gene pool” such as Kevin “Boxer” Moran are more likely to be drafted in to supplement the aforementioned progressives’ coalition with Fianna Fáil, though the stability of such a multi-dimensional partnership could prove to be problematic in the long run.
With 80 seats being the magic number for a majority, a grand coalition between Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael would be far more stable arithmetically. A partnership between Fianna Fáil and Sinn Féin would offer the same stability from a numbers’ perspective. However, if you are to take Micheál Martin at face value, both of those possibilities have been refuted repeatedly. Could we see a reversal of the current confidence and supply arrangement, this time with Fine Gael supporting a Fianna Fáil led government? The reality is, under the STV-PR system of voting, you can never be 100% sure what’s going to happen. One thing is for certain over the course of the weekend, we’re going to have plenty of drama. So whether you get up early in the morning, work nights or don’t work at all, be sure enjoy all the action and theatre on offer over the next 48 hours or so, and get out to exercise your democratic right, and Vote!
“It’s beginning to look a lot like Christmas” something I’m sure anybody even semi-regularly viewing their Instagram stories over the last few days will be in little doubt of. The dulcet tones of Bing Crosby, or in some sacrosanct cases, Michael Bublé, accompany panoramic, ambient videos, often filtered in black and white, presenting idyllic festive scenes such as the perfectly set dining table, an expertly accessorised coniferous tree or perhaps even the clinking of prosecco glasses in boomerang form. Now I enjoy Mickey Bubbles as much as the next man, but for me, Crosby’s version of the aforementioned Christmas classic is without parallel, Bublé’s effort on the other hand, not for me.
Anyway, I digress. If you were to speak to any Labour Party supporter in the UK in the early hours of Friday the 13th just gone, particularly those who had consumed much of their election coverage via Twitter, whether or not it looked anything like Christmas would have been quite low on their list of priorities. Labour had just produced its worst General Election performance since 1935, handing the Conservatives a 74-seat majority in the process. While many pollsters had anticipated a narrow Conservative majority in the lead up to polling day, those of a social democratic persuasion would have been forgiven for taking solace in their Twitter feeds that there was a chance of an upset. Unfortunately for them, when it comes to an individual’s Twitter feed and the question from one user to another is the same as Bing Crosby’s timeless enquiry “Do you see what I see?”, the answer is absolutely not.
For anybody with even a passing interest in politics, it would have been almost impossible to ignore proceedings from across the Irish Sea just under a fortnight ago. When I logged into my own Twitter account on election night, I was met with a sea of red. Figures from the world of music, sport and entertainment as well as many more besides were posting messages indicating that they’d voted Labour. Some were fervent and passionate in their updates, imploring their followers to vote the same way as they had with videos and lengthy ‘threads’, while others simply tweeted a rose emoji. Both actions equally as transparent in terms of deciphering where their political allegiances lay. Imagine my surprise when details of the exit poll (below) came in. Imagine those Labour supporters actually in the UK, and all the hope and positivity of the preceding few hours, vanished in an instant, with one chime of Big Ben. So much of what you thought and convinced yourself to be true were, in the grand scheme of things, the thoughts of the few rather than the many.
Therein lies the problem of the echo chamber. The Oxford dictionary defines an echo chamber as “an environment in which somebody encounters only opinions and beliefs similar to their own, and does not have to consider alternatives”. We’ve become so accustomed to our apps, websites and devices constantly collecting and gathering our data, that it doesn’t really surprise us when Spotify creates the perfect personal playlist for us, or we open Facebook to an ad for accommodation in Bratislava just seconds after you’ve typed that very destination into Skyscanner. Twitter is no different when it comes to understanding our preferences better than we do ourselves.
Upon clicking into your Twitter app, the primary domains are the algorithm-powered feeds, ‘Top Tweets’ and ‘In case you missed it’, which have replaced the traditional reverse chronological order of tweets as the default setting, that the website initially launched with in 2006. According to Twitter, the tweets that appear in those primary domains are specifically selected for you “based on the accounts you interact with most, the tweets you engage with and much more”. The recency of a tweet’s publishing, the account’s number of followers and level of activity, as well the type of media included, also inform Twitter of the type of content that users like to see of their site. For example, the more 30-second videos you engage with on Twitter, the more tweets of that nature you’re going to see. The same logic applies to liking, retweeting and commenting on the platform. Obviously, the more time you spend scrolling through your Twitter feed and interacting with tweets, the better the website understands your preferences. Therefore, it’s very easy to see how a user can become trapped within a Twitter-shaped echo chamber and thus lulled into the heightened sense of self-assuredness and confidence in one’s opinions that such an environment affords.
Not only can Twitter’s algorithms contribute to the creation of echo chambers by showing users content and opinions that they broadly support and agree with, but its engagement-driven model is also likely to churn out the more extreme points of opposition rather than a more measured, middle of the road view. In the hyper-partisan environment that online debate has now become, one of the few times people tend to engage with those holding a different opinion is when that opinion is so abhorrent and egregious to them, or in some instances even downright ludicrous, that they feel compelled to share it with their followers. See Piers Morgan taking the gender identity debate to an extreme, claiming that he wished to identify as a penguin, or the routine reply to any tweet criticising Jeremy Corbyn’s handling of alleged antisemitism in the Labour Party; “Fuck off and join the Tories”. Then on a slightly lighter note, there’s “Turtleneck Man” inadvertently advocating for a United Ireland on BBC’s Question Time as a solution to then Brexit deadlock, or just when we thought we were all on the same page, we have Shane Ross posting a picture of his cooked Christmas goose. As long as the outrage or ridicule manifests itself in clicks, comments or quoted retweets, then guess what? Twitter’s going to show us more of it.
The point here being, if the only opposition you encounter to your pre-existing views comes from people you find either morally repugnant, ignorant or even just a bit stupid, then it’s so much easier to disagree and find fault with that opposition. The more we argue about our position with these types of people, the more certain that we are, in fact, correct. Add into the mix how the faceless, and oftentimes anonymous nature of social media interaction can make people more verbally aggressive than they would be in person. This only enhances the perception that those on the other side are either not nice people or clueless, and in some instances, both. Ultimately, Twitter’s engagement-driven, algorithm-powered model also leaves us prone to this type of confirmation bias on top of creating the conditions conducive to the construction of an echo chamber. However, it’s not all doom and gloom.
Three Professors of Information Systems from Boston University and Hong Kong Science & Technology University teamed up earlier this year to write a paper for MIT’s Sloan Management Review titled ‘Twitter Is Not The Echo Chamber We Think It Is’. They found that the average Twitter account “posts links to more politically moderate news sources than the ones they receive on their own feed”. However, the most active and followed 1% of users analysed, who the study refers to as “core users” bucked this trend, tending to post more partisan content than what they were actually exposed to in their own feeds. These “core users” included politicians, commentators as well as other individuals and organisations whose main interests revolve around current affairs and news. While the authors of the piece felt the perception of polarisation on Twitter might be greater than it is in reality, it is the very characteristics of these “core users”, highly active with large followings, that factor heavily in the website’s algorithms for ranking users’ tweets.
So as the decade draws to a close, the way in which we consume our news is almost already unrecognisable from ten years ago. We’re spending more time looking at our phone screens and in turn moving away from the traditional forms of media that have dominated for so many decades gone by. We have never had such a vast array of information available to us before, nor has there been so many different sources and places to obtain that information. Twitter has played a pivotal role in all of this, with users only one viral tweet away from becoming ‘mainstream’, however temporary or short-lived it may be. People far cleverer than you and I, whether they’re bastions of the traditional media landscape, or new kids on the block with a point or two to prove, are already tapping into this and producing the content most likely to drive interaction and engagement, and ultimately, increase their reach. By all means, continue to use Twitter and social media for all the weird and wonderful content it provides, just stay vigilant, healthily sceptical and take heed of Mickey Bubbles’ advice; “Keep on loving what is true, and the world will come to you”. You might just have to look a bit harder for the truth yourself.
“What is the cost of lies? It’s not that we’ll mistake them for the truth. The real danger is that if we hear enough lies, then we no longer recognise the truth at all”. Rather chillingly, the opening remarks of Valery Legasov in HBO’s recent dramatisation of the events surrounding the Chernobyl nuclear disaster 33 years ago are still very relevant today. Nowhere in public discourse and so close to home, is this more apparent than in the debate around the United Kingdom’s exit from the European Union (EU). While there is a thesis in itself on the events that have brought us to where we are today, this piece takes on the rather daunting task of a slightly more condensed explanation of ‘Brexit to Date’ without any of the rhetoric or mistruths.
Taking Back Control?
Given all the talk of “catastrophic impacts” and “Doomsday scenarios”, particularly on this side of the Irish Sea, the most pertinent question to ask to begin this analysis is ‘How did it all come to this?’
Initially the inclusion of a promise to hold an in-or-out referendum on EU membership in the Conservative Party’s 2015 General Election manifesto was an effort by David Cameron to appease an “increasingly assertive anti-EU wing” within the party as well as to discourage its supporters from switching allegiances to the increasingly popular United Kingdom Independence Party (UKIP). However, not even the pollsters foresaw the 51.9%-48.1% result in favour of leaving the EU. With voter turnout at 72% on the day, what exactly influenced the British electorate to vote the way they did?
YouGov’s (2016) result breakdown is telling is this regard, showing that those over 65 were twice as likely to vote ‘Leave’ as people under 25. Also, 68% of voters with a university degree wished to Remain, while 70% of those who’s highest “educational attainment” was at GCSE level or lower voted to Leave the EU. Geographically, the Greater London area was the only region in England to vote ‘Remain’, alongside only Northern Ireland and Scotland. Based on these facts, it’s difficult to argue that the differing levels of economic prosperity experienced by these two broad demographics; older, less formally qualified voters from the north of England and young, university educated voters living near London, didn’t have a major impact on the electorate’s decision. The perceived impact of immigration rates and Brussels’ level of involvement in British politics and law-making on this economic disparity and other societal issues were some of the main factors promoted and pushed by those campaigning for a Leave vote. One particularly striking and controversial image demonstrating this was, then UKIP leader Nigel Farage’s ‘Breaking Point’ poster (below).
While Farage was roundly criticised for the poster, it does display just how evocative the imagery and language used on that side of the campaign was. This is highlighted by Steve Buckledee in his book ‘The Language of Brexit’ about how the Leave campaign used language far more persuasively than their Remain advocating counterparts. He suggests that it is very difficult to sound impassioned and to energise people when the basis of your message is essentially that it’s “better to stick with the status quo”, especially when that means “persevering with a historically uneasy relationship” with the EU, one of who’s Four Economic Freedoms involves the free movement of people. Contrast this with an appeal to “a traditional sense of national pride”, “love of liberty” and to “Take Back Control” of your country. There’s only one winner in the emotive stakes. Moreover, a survey mentioned by Fintan O’Toole in his own book on Brexit, further reinforces this. Voters were asked to choose from a list of four positive, and four negative words about how EU membership made them feel the night before polling day. 44% of respondents selected ‘unease’ from this list, perhaps fuelled by some of the aforementioned rhetoric and stirring sentiment, which illustrates a certain anxiety that existed among the British electorate before they went to the polls to decide the future of the UK-EU relationship. To quote O’Toole directly “a great salve to anxiety, is control”.
Strategy
“I’ve been wondering what that special place in hell looks like, for those who promoted Brexit, without even a sketch of a plan how to carry it out safely”. Donald Tusk, President of the European Council, speaking after talks with Taoiseach Leo Varadkar back in February this year sent shockwaves around Europe. However, his feelings were indicative of the EU’s frustrations with the Brexit negotiations and a damning indictment on just how disjointed and scattered the UK’s strategy has been since the shock result over three years ago now.
At the very heart of this debacle is the issue of our border with Northern Ireland, which after Brexit will be the only land border between the UK and the EU. It has been one of the largest stumbling blocks for the UK as they attempt to negotiate a withdrawal agreement. Ignorance of the potential problems posed by such a border were a common theme throughout the initial campaign, although remarkably, not only from the Leave side. Chris Cook reported correspondence from sources within the UK diplomatic service, that revealed Irish civil servants were seeking clarity at EU summits on this issue over a year out from the referendum, while then Prime Minister David Cameron’s contingency plan for such a scenario in the event a Leave victory “was not losing [the referendum]”.
Consensus building, or lack thereof, has been a significant factor in both the Irish border question and the Brexit negotiations in general. “Consensus is a dread weapon” in any negotiation, to borrow from Chris Cook once more, and the fact that 48% of UK voters wished to Remain in the EU was a major disadvantage in trying to attain such ammunition. Add into the mix the triggering of Article 50 in March 2017, under pressure from the EU. This gave the UK merely two years to negotiate a withdrawal agreement from the EU, before it had any real idea what type of Brexit the country had voted for. Was the mandate for a hard/soft Brexit? Did the people want to remain in the Single Market for example? There simply hadn’t been enough time to gather that sort of information. Just three weeks later, new PM Theresa May (having replaced David Cameron after the referendum) called a general election in an attempt to achieve that desired consensus and strong mandate for steering the UK out of the EU. Unfortunately for May, this proved disastrous with her Conservative party actually losing 13 seats and in turn their majority, forcing them to rely on the support of the Pro-Brexit DUP to remain in government. This was just one of the strategic errors made by May and her government in their bid to get a suitable withdrawal deal over the line.
Having initially campaigned for the UK to ‘Remain’, Theresa May was somewhat of a surprise choice as Tory leader given the referendum’s mandate to do the exact opposite. To exhibit her commitment to the cause she set up a new government department for exiting the EU and appointed a number of “Hard Brexiteers” such as Boris Johnson, Liam Fox and David Davis to key positions. This would ultimately create further problems for May down the line.
At various points over the last three years, May has reiterated her commitment to avoid a “return to the borders of the past”, and the inclusion of the “Backstop” in November 2018’s Withdrawal Agreement reaffirmed this. If it was passed, Northern Ireland would be aligned to some additional EU Single Market regulations that the rest of the UK was not, to ensure the border between the two countries remains as open as it is currently, thereby effectively creating a customs/regulatory border down the Irish Sea. Fundamentally, this was never going to wash with her coalition partners, the DUP, who wouldn’t tolerate any differences between Northern Ireland and the rest of the UK. Neither did it satisfy some of the harder Brexiteers in the Tory party, many of whom had been appointed by May to high-responsibility positions in her advisory team, because it would mean the UK was still heavily linked with the EU’s Single Market. Therefore, after three iterations of essentially the same Withdrawal Agreement, all including the backstop, were put before the House of Commons and rejected, with the second vote’s failure prompting an extension of the negotiation process to October, Theresa May resigned.
In the end it was her ill-judged snap election, and her party’s resulting coalition partners along with the hard Brexiteers that she chose to include in her close-knit group of advisors and negotiators, that were her undoing. It simply wasn’t possible to get a deal that would maintain an open Irish Border, avoid intra-UK borders and have an independent trade policy i.e. one that satisfied all parties.
“Where do we go from here?”
On the announcement of the Brexit deadline extension back in March, Donald Tusk was quick to warn the UK “Please do not waste this time”. However, a significant portion of that time since the extension, and Mrs. May’s subsequent resignation was taken up by internal Conservative Party politics as they went about choosing their new leader, who would be charged with delivering Brexit as the UK’s new Prime Minister. The issue of the border in Ireland, the same dilemma that ultimately brought down the previous PM, still faces her successor. In spite of this, the remaining contenders for the keys to Number Ten, Boris Johnson and Jeremy Hunt, reiterated throughout their respective campaigns that the “backstop must be removed completely before they would accept any withdrawal deal.
The 22nd of July confirmed what many had been expecting for most of the campaign, Boris Johnson was elected as leader of the Conservative Party, and more importantly the country’s next Prime Minister. In the end, the votes of just 92,153 of his own party members were enough get him there, a statistic that sheds some light on what type of Brexit the Tory party wants, though still a long way off achieving the consensus that negotiators so crave, regarding the Brexit desires of the rest of the British electorate. What the result of the leadership contest, and the commentary surrounding the campaign does suggest, is that voters believe that Boris, through his unorthodox and slightly maverick style of politics and a sense that “he has something up his sleeve”, will be able to get the country a satisfactory deal that conventional politics and politicians have failed to deliver over the course of the last three years.
Since becoming Prime Minister, Boris has certainly endeavoured to maintain that eccentric persona that so many credit for his rise to the top job. He has persisted with the evocative and passionate language that proved so successful for the Leave campaign, already promising that he would lead the UK out of the EU before the 31st of October “Come what may”, while also stating he would rather “die in a ditch” than remain beyond that ever-nearing deadline. That same language has also characterised much of his cabinet’s proclamations on the Brexit issue. At last week’s Conservative Party Conference in Manchester, Jacob Rees-Mogg, Leader of the House of Commons, praised the “force and charisma” that Boris has brought to negotiations with the EU, while Home Secretary, Priti Patel vowed to end the free movement of people “once and for all”. At this juncture however, it’s important to look at whether anything of substance has actually been achieved during Johnson’s premiership to suggest that the UK will leave with a satisfactory deal by the end of the month.
Since getting the keys to Number Ten, Boris and his government have yet to win a single vote in the House of Commons, losing seven divisions in succession, along with its working majority on its first sitting day of parliament after the passing of the ‘Benn Act’. This defeat will likely prove detrimental to Johnson’s Brexit plans in more ways than one. Not only does the Benn Act mandate the prime minister to seek an extension to the current Brexit deadline if parliament doesn’t consent to a withdrawal agreement or leaving without a deal by the 19th of October, but its support by 21 rebel, Conservative party MPs has resulted in them losing the party whip and in turn, their expulsion from the party. Those expelled by Johnson include Ken Clarke, an MP of 49 years who has the longest record of continuous service in the House of Commons, and Nicholas Soames, a grandson of the man who Boris has described as a political hero of his, Winston Churchill. The obvious backlash from many traditional Tory supporters aside, the expulsions of so many party stalwarts among others creates a basic parliamentary arithmetic issue. The government no longer has a majority. This meant recent attempts to call another snap general election were scuppered, and only further increases the influence that parliament has on the type of Brexit the UK is going to get.
Perhaps foreseeing the writing on the wall regarding the impending Commons defeats, days prior to his first sitting day of parliament as prime minister, Johnson declared he had asked the Queen to prorogue parliament for five weeks to allow for the government to set out a new legislative agenda. If granted, it would have been the longest prorogation since 1930 and with a new session only beginning on the 14th of October, so close to the deadline, many questioned its justification, suggesting it was a move designed to evade parliamentary scrutiny of the government’s Brexit plans. Despite Johnson and other cabinet members’ insistence that the prorogation had “nothing to do with Brexit”, the UK Supreme Court unanimously ruled it to be unlawful and therefore null and of no effect. This is in addition to a ruling by the highest civil court in Scotland, the Court of Session sitting in Edinburgh which also found the prorogation to be unlawful, adding that it had the “improper purpose of stymieing parliament”. With the power of the UK courts also evident for all to see and their steadfast support and recognition of parliament’s importance, Johnson’s options appear to be dwindling if he wants to make good on all of his Brexit promises.
The issue of the Irish border remains the largest stumbling block to a mutually beneficial withdrawal agreement. The backstop, or a version of a customs border down the Irish sea is conceivably back on the table given that the government has lost its majority and therefore, in theory, no longer requires the support of the DUP. Nigel Dodds, a DUP MP has even conceded that there could be some arrangements of an all-Ireland nature if they were to benefit each of Ireland, Northern Ireland and the EU. Given both the legal and parliamentary pressure on Boris to strike a deal, one would think he might consider such an option, however his latest rather convoluted proposals involving “customs clearance sites” and GPS tracking technology that would effectively require the erecting of customs posts on both sides of the border, would suggest otherwise. The need for physical infrastructure at the border is not compatible with the Good Friday Agreement,and thus makes it nigh on impossible for the EU to support such an arrangement.
Without a significant shift in the British position on the border issue, it’s very hard to see how an acceptable agreement can be struck in such a short period of time. Last Friday saw the government submit papers to the court of session in Edinburgh suggesting that the prime minister is bound by law to request an extension if no deal is agreed by the 19th of October. Though just hours later, Boris took to social media to contradict this, tweeting “No deal or new deal – but no delay”. Just how serious are he, and his government about negotiating a new deal? Does Boris actually believe that the UK can thrive in a no deal scenario? Given that the man penned two conflicting columns during the referendum, one advocating Remain, and the other supporting a Leave vote, before choosing the most personally advantageous position to take up, is it even fair to expect Boris to be able to identify his true feelings and opinions on the matter, amongst all the rhetoric and his many promises? One thing that his government’s actions over the last few months does seem to convey, is that he very much wanted to retain the threat of no deal in negotiations at the very least. Ironically however, it has been the power of the UK parliament and judicial system, oft maligned and dismissed during the referendum for it links to the EU, that looks to have taken back control as it were, and removed that option from the table for the time being, without any interference from Brussels or Strasbourg.
Less than a fortnight out from the current deadline and chances of a deal slim, yet another extension appears to be the most likely outcome at this point, meaning that for one of the most gripping and polarising political dramas in recent history, we may have to wait until 2020 for its resolution.